Overanticipation leads to disappointment.
I mention this because I finally received my much-anticipated copy of True Love Waits and have mixed feelings after listening to the CD.
When I bought the CD, I was looking forward to three particular tracks: Fake Plastic Trees, True Love Waits, and Motion Picture Soundtrack. Indeed, it was Christopher O'Riley's live performance of an abbreviated version of Fake Plastic Trees that had me sold on the CD. And to his credit, O'Riley's full-length version of the Radiohead song recreates and builds on the original—staying true to the sentiments while intensifying the emotion. I think Fake Plastic Trees is almost reason enough to buy the CD.
I first heard the title track from the short snippet on the album's official site. After hearing a recording of the original's first live performance, I looked forward to hearing O'Riley's version, which seemed to do a better job of capturing the song's quiet, pleading emotion. And for the first two thirds of the track, it does just that—O'Riley starts with the song's plaintive melody and patiently weaves in other themes, one strand at a time. He preserves the song's tenderness while building an increasingly complex web of harmonies that accentuate the original melody. Unfortunately, O'Riley doesn't stop—the song climaxes in a frenzy that overpowered the theme. It felt like an unnecessary indulgence on O'Riley's part to showcase his technical mastery without enhancing the piece.
Ok, I'm tired, so I don't want to say too much about Motion Picture Soundtrack. It also fell victim to excess, though not as severely as True Love Waits—O'Riley concludes an otherwise moving piece with a few measures of an overwrought ending.